Pizzeria New York Menu (Update 2025)

Welcome to Pizzeria New York, where authentic Italian pizza meets the heart of Pickerington, OH. Nestled at 833 Hill Rd N, this pizzeria boasts a menu filled with classic favorites that have patrons raving.

• Sicilian Pizza - A must-try at $17.99, this dish embodies the rich, robust flavors reminiscent of New York.
• Spaghetti or Penne - Perfectly paired with zesty tomato sauce, this comforting option is priced at just $7.95.
• Chicken Fingers - Served with a variety of indulgent sauces, these tender bites make for a delightful starter at $7.99.

With rave reviews highlighting the pizza’s homemade feel and authentic crust, Pizzeria New York offers an experience that feels genuinely special. If you seek a slice of New York in Ohio, look no further—this pizzeria is where your pizza dreams will come true!