Welcome to Pizzeria New York, a hidden gem nestled at 833 Hill Rd N in the heart of Pickerington, Ohio. If you’re on the lookout for authentic Italian-style pizza, this place is a must-try. Since its inception, Pizzeria New York has garnered a reputation for serving some of the finest pies in the area, and for good reason.

The ambience may be unassuming—often empty during weeknights as patrons opt for takeout—but don’t let that fool you. As Andrea Rudin aptly put it, "Do not sleep on this place!" The authentic flavors and textures promise a decadent experience, reminiscent of a bustling pizzeria in the New York City or New Jersey area.

• Sicilian Pizza: At just $17.99, this pizza boasts a thick crust that's crispy on the outside yet soft and chewy inside. It's perfect for those who enjoy a hearty bite.
• Pizza Sub: Priced at $5.45, this offering combines pepperoni, mozzarella, and robust pizza sauce to create a delightful handheld meal that’s bursting with flavor.
• Chicken Fingers: A favorite among families, these tenders come with a choice of flavorful sauces for only $7.99. Perfect for a lighter, yet satisfying accompaniment to your pizza.
• Spaghetti or Penne: For pasta lovers, this dish for $7.95 features a classic tomato sauce that creates a comforting and familiar Italian dining experience.
• Tossed Salad: A fresh accompaniment at $7.99, with iceberg lettuce, red onions, and tomatoes, it’s crafted to balance out the main dish perfectly.

The reviews from satisfied customers speak volumes about their experience. Alex Becerra describes the pizza as "great" and notes the homemade feel of the crust with delightful toppings like banana peppers. Similarly, Adam Chinny praises the consistency, stating, "Never had a bad experience here." It's clear that the passion for pizza is evident in every slice.

Rosie Brown, a self-proclaimed connoisseur of New York pizza, remarks, "This is the closest to authentic NY style pizza that I've found outside NY." With carefully crafted dishes, it's evident that the commitment to quality is a cornerstone of Pizzeria New York's philosophy. Every ingredient is selected with care, ensuring each pie is a testament to the pizzeria's dedication to Italian traditions.

Whether you’re a longtime fan of New York-style pizza or a newcomer seeking to indulge in a culinary adventure, Pizzeria New York is undoubtedly a standout choice in the Columbus area. If you're looking for a true pizza experience, don't hesitate to give this pizzeria a try—you won't leave disappointed!